Skip to main content

Is your roof old or damaged? Get a free estimate today

« View All Posts

Roofing Contractors

Top 5 Roofing Companies in West Allis

December 9, 2022 | 4 min. read

Print/Save as PDF

Roofing issues like leaks and missing shingles can be frustrating – and then you hear the words “you need a roof replacement.” Making a big financial investment on top of other responsibilities can make buying a new roof devastating.

Finding the right contractor for you can make the process even harder. With so many roofing companies available in West Allis, Wisconsin, it can be frustrating to find the right roofing company for your needs.

How are you supposed to know that a roofing contractor is honest, trustworthy, and capable of providing you with an exceptional roofing experience? That is why Rescue My Roof has compiled the top 5 companies servicing the West Allis, Wisconsin area.

While Rescue My Roof has been in the roofing industry for over a decade, we recognize that we may not be the best fit for everyone. But that doesn’t mean we can’t help you find the contractor you’re meant to hire. 

Below, in no particular order, is a list of the top five best roofing companies servicing West Allis, WI. With this list, you’ll be able to find the roofing contractor of your dreams. And at the end, we’ll give you a downloadable guide to get you through the roofing process.

The Best Roofing Companies in West Allis, WI

When we were creating this list, we considered what companies we would call to do our own roof.

These contractors have been in the business at least five to ten years, have a good reputation, and deliver on their warranties.

All of these qualities may make them the perfect fit for you and your home. 

1. Noffke Roofing Co. LLC

“Noffke Roofing did repair work and a partial roof replacement on our commercial roof and they did a very nice, professional job. Kudos to Ben Noffke in particular. He took the time to prepare a detailed quote on our roof and answered any questions I had… I would highly recommend them!”

Dason S.

Founded: 1952

Headquarters: Mequon, WI

Areas Serviced: Milwaukee, Ozaukee, Washington, Waukesha, and Racine Counties

Noffke Roofing has been serving southern Wisconsin since 1952, offering full-service roofing on all roof types from EPDM to liquid coatings to wood and asphalt shingles. 

They offer repair and installation services for commercial, residential, church, and specialty/historical buildings. Noffke Roofing aligns their mission with this statement: “Serve our customers with the excellence they deserve.” 

2. Semper Fi Roofing & Exteriors

“The Semper Fi team was very professional and courteous… They went the extra mile to make sure all our questions and concerns were addressed and during the project made sure my property was left in the same if not better condition than when they arrived. I would definitely recommend them to anyone looking to replace their roof.”

Jeffrey F.

Founded: 2003

Headquarters: Mukwonago, WI

Areas Serviced: Cedarburg, West Bend, Jackson, Grafton, Saukville, Milwaukee County, Delafield, Delevan

Semper Fi is a local, veteran-owned, family-operated Milwaukee roofing company that offers roof installation and repairs. Additionally, they also offer exterior siding, windows and doors, and gutter replacements. 

Their primary focus is to provide customers with a great experience and the highest quality products in the industry. They are heavily involved in the Milwaukee community by supporting the Semper Fi Fund and sponsoring the Veterans in Need Sweepstakes. 

3. Allrite Home & Remodeling

“Jordan and his crew were the absolute best to work with. We did a complete home exterior renovation with them including widows, exterior doors, and siding. The final product was amazing and we could not have been more pleased. Would definitely recommend them.”

Joseph B.

Founded: 1969

Headquarters: Milwaukee, WI

Areas Serviced: Milwaukee County

Allrite Home & Remodeling has been family-owned since 1969, and their mission is to allow homeowners to have the unique look they’re looking for and always meet their needs. 

They have been awarded the 2021 Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Top Choice Awards: Best Siding Contractor Winner and specialize in siding, windows and doors, and roofing. 

4. Paragon Exteriors

“Paragon Exteriors did an excellent job on our roof. In fact, they did our roof twice in a year due to a horrible hail storm that caused our neighborhood to be declared a disaster area… They were responsive, quick, efficient, and thorough. Thank you Paragon for your work.”

Nick J.

Founded: 2009

Headquarters: Eagle, WI

Areas Serviced: Waukesha and Milwaukee counties

Paragon Exteriors are factory-certified installers for CertainTeed and Owens Corning Shingles. They specialize in roof replacements and repairs on commercial buildings, condos, and other large residential buildings. 

Unlike many contractors, Paragon Exteriors does not require down payments for residential roofing projects. So if you don’t have the 25 or 50 percent deposit that most companies ask for, Paragon may be the right option for you. 

5. Infinity Exteriors LLC

“The Infinity team performed well from the initial meeting through final delivery and closing out the project. They were on-time and cleaned up extremely well each day… I would highly recommend them if you are considering improvements to the exterior of your home.”

Douglas E.

Founded: 2000

Headquarters: New Berlin, WI

Areas Serviced: Milwaukee, Fox Valley, and Dan Counties

Infinity Roofing not only holds the title of the largest exterior remodeling and roofing company in Wisconsin, but they offer many services beyond roofing. 

If you are looking for the complete package of windows, siding, insulation, and more, Infinity Exteriors will be able to get the job done. They have a team of experts dedicated to giving customers the best experience possible. 

Finding the Roofing Contractor For You

Now that you know the top five companies you’ll want to contact for an estimate, here are some additional resources for you. 

Make sure you find the right contractor for you by asking the nine questions listed in our article “9 Questions You Should Ask Before Hiring a Roofing Contractor.

You can also download our Buyer’s Guide! With our guide, you’ll find everything you need to get through the roof-buying process. 

And as always, Rescue My Roof is here to help. You can always call on us for a free estimate or any repair or replacement needs. You can book your estimation appointment free of charge. Contact us today to get started!